“As soon as you touch this limit, something happens, and you suddenly can go a little bit further. With your mind power, your determination, your instinct, and the experience as well, you can fly very high.” — Ayrton Senna, three-time Formula One World Champion
“If you are a straightforward racing driver, you should always see your limits. You have to be objective and not come up with any bullshit.” — Niki Lauda, three-time Formula One World Champion
Source: Arsenal.com
Where’s the limit?
One image of Piero Hincapié that sticks is from a match about ten days into Xabi Alonso’s tenure as Bayer Leverkusen manager.
The club was drifting near the bottom of the Bundesliga, winless in Europe, and in need of a jolt. Down a goal, the free-kick swerved in, and Hincapié hurled himself (and I do mean him’s entire self) into the header.
The ball crashed over the line, and he took off sprinting, arms pumping, embracing the delirium. It was a wildman’s goal and a wildman’s celebration. It was also a glimpse of what he has always been about: intensity, defiance, and a stubborn desire to throw himself into the fray.
But the joy was short-lived. The Glasner-led Eintracht goals came pouring in. Within fifteen minutes, Hincapié was sent off for a second yellow on a slippery pitch.
Leverkusen lost 5–1.
It was an appropriate snapshot of the moment. For Hincapié, it encapsulated some of the magnetic but rogue energy that saw him finish the season as an intriguing transfer target for clubs in the Premier League and beyond, but one with 13 yellows and three reds to his name.
It didn’t take long for Alonso to turn things around at Leverkusen. From late February through the start of May, the squad went unbeaten in all competitions, and Hincapié played a key role, starting 27 times in all.
This earned him local comparisons to Franz Beckenbauer, whose number he now claims at Arsenal. Phillip Arens, who covered Leverkusen for SPORT BILD, recalled how Hincapie’s nickname was ‘El Kaiser’.
“It's quite interesting to be honoured and named after a legend like Beckenbauer. When Piero had some very good matches, we asked Alonso about this comparison, and then he said: 'For me, he is not an emperor, he is a warrior.'
“Xabi was looking at him like a father. Piero was very much linked with Xabi.”
The next year was a dream. Thanks in no small part to a sweetheart deal for Granit Xhaka, Alonso’s system fully clicked. Hincapié matured while rotating more in a deeper squad. The same energy that once got him sent off in Frankfurt was harnessed for good.
In January of that campaign, facing RB Leipzig, he again threw his body at a set piece, this time in stoppage time. The ball again crashed over the line, and Hincapié again sprinted away, arms pumping, celebrating with abandon. The deadlock was broken, but there were no caveats after this one, only a final whistle.
It was a particularly magical moment in a season full of them. That May, Hincapié came on against Eintracht, instead of being sent off. The final score was also 5-1, but the other way around.
Leverkusen went unbeaten across the Bundesliga, winning their first league title, and Hincapié proved he could toe the line without crossing it.
That journey to invincibility began far from Germany.
Hincapié learned on the sand, winning multiple beach tournaments in his hometown of Esmeraldas, then going through local clubs before joining Independiente del Valle, Ecuador’s most influential academy, which has built a formidable reputation for developing talent: Moisés Caicedo, Kendry Páez, and Willian Pacho, to name a few. It was there that he learned the rhythms of a life in professional football. He helped lead his club to a first-ever U-20 Copa Libertadores, prevailing over a River Plate side featuring the likes of Enzo Fernández and Lucas Beltrán.
Next, he moved to Talleres de Córdoba in Argentina. Opportunity arrived in a flash. A starting defender went down injured, and Hincapié stepped in. He played 14 matches in the Professional Football League, two in the Argentine Cup, and six international matches in the Copa Sudamericana. The country is famously aggressive in its defending, from five-a-side to the Primera División: Argentina’s World Cup–winning centre-backs were Cristian Romero, Nicolás Otamendi, and Lisandro Martínez, after all. Gabriel Heinze, the Argentine defender who is now on Arsenal’s coaching staff, was never one to shy away from a challenge.
Perhaps Hincapié was influenced by this foray. Perhaps he just found those of like minds. In any case, by the following summer, Hincapié had skipped the national U-20 ladder entirely, debuting for Ecuador’s senior team at the Copa América. The buzz had begun in earnest.
When Bayer Leverkusen arrived in 2021, he deliberated. “I spoke to my family, to myself, to God — and I opted for Bayer 04,” he recalled. “I have great respect for the country and the language, and my family had always emphasised that a lot of Latinos play here — and some of them for many years. That was an important reason. Because if they stay here for a long time then they must feel at home.”
He found a way to bring his family along, tattooing his parents’ faces on his left leg. Next to their images, he added a phrase: “The driving force of my life.”
He did more than settle in Germany. In four years at the BayArena, he made 166 appearances, including 43 in the double-winning season. He is young but supremely experienced, including fourteen starts in the Champions League.
There is an obsessive streak in him. The club website wrote about the image of him on away trips back home: the bus winding through the mountains of Pichincha, volcanoes and valleys passing outside, while Hincapié stared only at his phone. On the screen was Sergio Ramos: slide tackles, headers, confidence. He would spend entire trips immersed in those clips, studying posture and timing.
Along the way, he was attracting the usual attention. Tottenham reportedly tested Leverkusen’s resolve with a €25m bid in the summer of 2023, which was roughly in line with his market value at the time; they were rebuffed. Then-Atlético Madrid sporting director Andrea Berta was reported to be “in love” with him. Liverpool and Arsenal also circled.
South American observers admitted they had misjudged him.
“I thought too spindly, maybe, and he’s got mistakes in him,” said Tim Vickery. “It’s been great to be proved wrong, because he’s grown and grown and really is a terrific defender. He’s not a flyer-up-the-wing kind of left-back. He likes to bring the ball out of defence.”
This last campaign, Leverkusen fell to second, but Hincapié had a season that was simply very good, with little nuance to attach to it. He logged the most minutes of his career, had the lowest fouling rate of his career, and his stats all popped.
“He is very fast, very aggressive in a positive way now, and he can also play very offensively with good crosses, and is very versatile. His flexibility makes him so good,” said Arens. “Alonso was so happy with his development.”
“Piero is a really superb guy,” he added. “He was very much respected by the fans here because he always left his heart on the pitch.”
Source: Arsenal.com
This summer, the battle raged anew. Questions had seemingly been answered, and Spurs again sought the signature of the Ecuadorian, but Berta, now with Arsenal, closed a creative loan obligation deal, just as Jakub Kiwior headed out to Porto.
Mikel Arteta, the childhood friend of Alonso (that Basque paternal figure in Hincapié’s German life), was the one who gave the thumbs-up to that Xhaka deal. This time, he celebrated one coming his way.
“Piero has a real physical presence, with his versatility and tactical flexibility giving us strong added defensive options. He is a big character, with a very good combination of both youth and maturity. He will make our squad stronger and more competitive as we continue into this season.”
Now, it’s time for Hincapié to throw himself headfirst into a challenge once again.
This is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
📖 Player overview
…and that graphic is how I learned we signed another “Martin.”
Onto the scouting report. We begin with the physical makeup.
➡️ Physical qualities
Putting positions aside, Hincapié is an impressive and Premier League–ready athlete. He looks built for the pace and relentlessness of the league. He’s quick, intense, and physical.
His intensity doesn’t flag, and he can be the hardest runner in the 95th minute, even if he’s just played a full game at left-back. That engine gives him repeatability in recovery sprints, pressing jumps, and overlaps that a lot of defenders can’t or don’t sustain. It’s a nice combination of fitness and focus.
Here, you can see him get to the ball first, burst on a carry, get fouled, and get back up for a supporting run.
He’s listed at 6’0”–6’1”, but plays tall, especially when against wingers. His upright carriage and long legs mean he doesn’t often look overmatched in the air; only, really, when trading shoulders with a bigger striker. Everything feels leggy, in a positive and negative sense: he’s always sticking a leg in, successful or not. This isn’t to say he’s ramrod-straight in a defensive duel like Ben White, who overcomes his unorthodox fundamentals; Hincapié is closer to a coaching video, knees bent and stance side-on.
His leap adds another layer: he can get up and contest headers against taller forwards, and while he’s not yet dominant, he doesn’t usually feel undersized. His pre-duel muscling has gotten better.
What separates him from the likes of Kiwior, White, and Calafiori is raw pace down the wing. Top speed is a noisy stat, and I’m always complaining about it; that said, the Champions League top-three were Hakimi, Haaland, and Mbappé, and that … sounds about right to me. Hincapié clocked in at 34.8 km/h, placing him among players like Theo Hernández and Joško Gvardiol.
He’s especially quick on the carry.
Off-ball, he can usually change direction fairly quickly and recover into shape with agility, which is crucial in the Premdesliga. On-ball, he lacks winger-like hip mobility (he can’t uncouple shoulders from hips in the way a true dribbler does) and is more about simplicity and economy of action. He does have a clean touch and a feeling of control.
He doesn’t have the strongest right foot, which will limit his play to the left. It’s not a true liability, but not particularly interesting or threatening either.
He’s between the body types of a CB and full-back, which is probably the point. He’s got internal strength and doesn’t get bounced around, but he isn’t built like the more beefy Premier League stoppers either. He looks tall, rangy, and chirpy in his challenges, relentless rather than imposing. That lankier frame can be an asset, but it does mean he has to win with timing and competitiveness more than sheer bulk.
For a 23-year-old, the physical base is already high-level, and there are enough battles on tape (Salah, Ekitike, Messi, etc) to feel reasonably confident about how he’ll stack up. His toughest battles are against the tightest technicians, who can work around his physicality.
📊 Statistical background
First things first: it is difficult to benchmark any CB, but especially wide back-three CBs, and especially if they’ve also spent time at LB and LWB.
Still, I think it’s fairest to compare Hincapie to full-backs, while also knowing that it will influence the numbers: he’ll have more touches, easier touches facing play, and have less presence in advanced areas. So with that, you’ll see a lot of what you may expect: high touches, high pass completion, high carries, fewer take-ons, and less advanced work.
In any case, what you see here is, basically, a nice statistical profile. What you’ll also see is that there is a pretty small sample for things like crosses, dribbles, and key passes.
Next, we can compare him to some other options at Arsenal, while again remembering the positional differences at play (not to mention the league adjustment).
What we’ll see here:
He’s a wide CB, so he has the most touches and on-ball responsibility of anybody in the chart. It is also generally lower-pressure, facing-play type touches.
As such, he has the most forward passes, short/medium passes, and long passes in the sample. The efficiency numbers look good.
The increased defensive activity is not easily attributable to possession differences: Leverkusen had more possession than Arsenal last year, based on raw percentage. That said, Bundesliga games are more frenetic and have more touches in them, and Leverkusen opponents actually had more touches than those of Arsenal. By eye test, he does seem more “active” than anyone else in the comparison set. It fits with the vision of a front-foot, aggressive defender.
The numbers for progressive runs, dribbles, and advanced touches aren’t too different from the current Arsenal stable.
He had around double the aerial duels of others in this sample. By eye test, and by analytics, this is a part of his game that he has really improved.
He also had fewer fouls than Timber or Calafiori, which was nice to see.
He’s got a fairly high risk tolerance on the ball; he has the second-highest “loss index,” after White.
It should give you a general sense of his previous areas of influence.
🏋🏽♂️ Role & playing experience
Under Xabi Alonso, Bayer Leverkusen generally employed a back-three system with two midfielders and three in attack. He’d call upon a more typical back-four when the opponent shape called for it, but here’s a look at the formation usage last year:
Source: Wyscout
…and here it is, the year before:
The style was based on pressing, structured build-up, and quick combinations to burst through the thirds. The 3-2 initial possession shape, with a coherent and durable double-pivot, would feed the ball to more swirling attacking options. The wide full-backs would preserve width, while a middle-three of forwards would have their fun.
In this system, Hincapié has mostly been deployed as a wide, back-three LCB.
Source: Opta
For aggregated career appearances, Transfermarkt has us covered.
Source: transfermarkt
This looked about as you’d expect. Here he is performing back-three build-up as Grimaldo floats around ahead.
Here, you’ll see him as an LCB in a more expected setup.
For Ecuador, he can play both LB and LCB. He’s had great performances in this clean and straightforward setup. As extreme as it sounds, he is at least in the running to be the best defender Ecuador has ever produced.
At Leverkusen, he’s done spot starts as a bombing wing-back, but his secondary role was as an LB when Alonso decided to go with a standard back-four.
He looked plenty comfortable out there.
In sum: Hincapié has logged significant minutes as a left-sided centre-back in a back four, a wide stopper in a back three, and a defensively solid but progressive left-back, giving him a fairly unique blend of “hybrid” exposure across the roles on the left side.
🧠 Game temperament
Hincapié is a forceful, active, anticipatory, and highly aggressive presence on the pitch. As a teammate, he’s always switched on, pointing and talking, and wants everyone around him to follow suit. He’s played with a wild streak, joyful but domineering.
That edge spilled over in his early years. He picked up the aforementioned amount of cards in 22/23: 13 yellows, 3 reds in all. In his entire career (across comps, including his work with the national team), he’s up to 46 yellows and 6 reds.
Sometimes, that has been through specific lunges that looked reckless: he had a bad one against Julian Weigl where he was out of control and came down through his leg. He definitely has been guilty of the thing where he makes a mistake and overcompensates with a hard tackle right after.
Other times, it feels cumulative, a persistent aggression that weakened his odds. I went back and watched every red, and taken in sum, very few of them were fully boneheaded. He just lived on the line too often, and didn’t earn the benefit of the doubt.
More recently, he has reined things in. In less time, his card count dropped dramatically in the title-winning year, from 0.48 yellows/90 to 0.12, and from 3 reds to none. Last year, he logged his fewest fouls per 90, and again didn’t have a red. He wouldn’t be the first player to start from a place of impatience and learn to turn the dials to their most effective setting.
Here he is against Messi. 🙂
On the ball, his temperament is almost the opposite. His decision-making is clean, steady, and feels at the right level of ambition. He feels very cultured, intelligent, and well-coached. His first touches prepare him well, and he seems content to read the game without forcing it. That contrast, of being ferocious in duels but composed in possession, is part of what makes him unique.
There are still moments where his temperament edges into impatience. He tries to be heroic on recovery runs and sometimes over-exerts himself. He will still sometimes dive in when staying on his feet might have been enough.
But overall, the trajectory feels fairly linear. The fiery kid with a red-card problem is becoming a more measured competitor who still brings intensity, communication, and bite. Because you’re more likely to arrive late in a Premier League challenge, though, it’s something to keep monitoring.
It is my view that “traditional” LBs should be considered if they have extraordinary base characteristics. But CBs and midfielders are just so talented and versatile these days, and a more typical LB can have trouble finding other uses, so you’d really like to be sure. You’d really just want somebody to be comfortable in 2-3 spots here.
So, with that, we’ll keep an immediate opportunity (left-back) in mind. But more widely, let’s find a great, dynamic, left-sided defender who suits the long-term vision of the club and could slot in different ways.
Here are the parameters I’ve laid out. A job description of sorts.
Required
At least one standout/additive physical/dynamic quality
Active and engaged in the duel
High-level press resistor and progressor (either great at deep passing, forward dribbling, or both)
Can underlap or hold width on left
Tenacious but controlled, particularly when making decisions in counter-press
Not heavily foot-dominant
Either a full two-way player or overpowered enough in attack to be winger depth
Foundation of being a top-10 defender in the world, even if uncertain
Strongly preferred
Left-footed
Can start at left-back against any height of block
Positive on set plays
Ready to make an immediate impact
Excellent ball-striking
Tidy interplay with LW
Lightly preferred
Can start at 2+ other positions
Tall and set play dominant
When in doubt
Target the most impressive base profile
It’s still early, but you can see some of the potential squad-building issues with specialist full-backs right now in Liverpool’s signing of Milos Kerkez. Because Slot’s right-back is also pushing forward, Kerkez has been asked to play the role of a hybrid, usually playing like a “Reverse Ben White” on the left, facing play during second-phase build-up, joining the attacking line in spurts, and often looking awkward and jerky while doing so. He’s pretty clearly a wide bomber.
The issue is that if they need a hybrid, which is not Kerkez, he doesn’t have other deployments: you can’t really throw him on as a left-winger, a midfielder, or a CB. It’s a squad limiter. It’s the same thing that requires one to be “sure,” or as sure as one can be, when signing a specialist striker. All things held constant, you look for somebody with more flexible uses.
Now, since we wrote all that about LB/LCBs, things have changed a bit:
Jakub Kiwior, Oleksandr Zinchenko, and Kieran Tierney are gone.
Riccardo Calafiori and Cristhian Mosquera have been added to the backline.
Myles Lewis-Skelly emerged as one of the better left-backs in the league last year, but his future is probably in midfield.
Perhaps most importantly, Eberechi Eze and Noni Madueke have joined the attack. This changes a few things: pure, individual explosiveness has been gained; Eze likes to get inside, and would benefit from a wide left-back; Madueke is an option as a width-holder, who can help more inverted archetypes drive inside.
Interesting.
🎯 My priors
In that LB/LCB article from 2024, Hincapié ranked #28. There was only a short blurb:
I have watched a lot of Piero Hincapié. His numbers pop, and I’ve seen him be aggressive to the point of detriment. In reality, he is a really appealing player, but I’ve just seen some extremes in his performance levels. Undecided.
I’m not sure I was even aware of the card issues. I’d just seen him doing a lot of sweeping slide tackles.
Watched a fair bit of Hincapié for Neverlusen. Was both intrigued and measured. Fascinating profile (mobile, good touch, so quick, strong/pushy), but was *so* aggro, going to ground constantly, that I wrote “undecided.” I didn’t follow him as closely last year. I’ll catch up.
Expanding:
Stats pop, the physical quality is unique. He’s one of those “create-a-player” hybrids who can cover all three points of the triangle: wide/overlaps, step up like a high eight, glide/carry in midfield, box crash. I imagine Arteta has good intel from Xabi Alonso.
Based on priors, I’ve been a pretty happy boy this summer.
There’s a first group: players like Zubimendi and Eze are some of my absolute faves, for years, objectivity be damned, even if I think Eze was a little pricey; Madueke as a “third” attacking signing is almost inarguable, how fun and exciting; Mosquera is fascinating and has roughly been performing twice as good as a reasonable person could have assumed — the price was incredible, and he is also simply better than I thought; Kepa is exactly the type of GK signing I’d hoped for, as I’m very high on Raya, and think he’s got a few strong years left, and wouldn’t have splurged there unless it was for a rare profile (Joan García does fit that).
The second group contains my more measured takes: Christian Nørgaard and Viktor Gyökeres. You can’t find a better midfielder than Nørgaard at that price, and I did want a veteran there, but I worry about trading passing quality for physicality in the midfield again. With Gyökeres, I’m an “idealist without illusions,” as they say, though the price was fine.
On priors, Hincapié was somewhere in the middle, and probably closer to group two than one. He’s the exact kind of hybrid I would target in today’s game, as I outlined earlier. I also thought his athletic profile, and his level of application, would translate cleanly to the league. But I had watched him earlier in his career, and worried that he was a “young man in a hurry” in a detrimental way, and wondered whether he had that final level of attacking tidiness to generate a consistent threat, as we ask of our full-backs. “Undecided” was an accurate way to put it.
As I didn’t watch him much last year, I was interested to learn more.
👉 Showing my work
For Hincapié, I watched full matches or all-action clips against Dortmund, Bayern (twice), Liverpool, Atalanta, Paraguay, Argentina (twice, including one where he played LB opposite Messi, though that wasn’t a pure 1v1 as Messi drifted), Brazil, Chelsea, and … us in a friendly.
I also compiled a 212-clip playlist in Wyscout, isolating defensive duels, recoveries, carries, and passing sequences. The idea was to see him through multiple lenses (as an LB, as an LCB, and as an LWB) and to stress-test him against different levels of competition. I weighted the sample toward the past year, since that’s when I had seen him least, and wanted to check for development.
📄 Scouting report
Onward.
👉 Out-of-possession
Hincapié thrives in the duel. He trusts his feet, his recovery pace, and his aggression. In the Premier League, that mindset will need continued calibration, so he stays on his feet a touch longer, takes slightly more conservative angles against faster wingers, and picks spots for challenges. The core tools (agility, timing, sheer ability to go again and again) are all there to make him a consistently good defender in 1v1 situations.
➡️ Duels & 1v1 Defending
Source of these: Wyscout
Hincapié’s duels are built around front-foot intensity. It’s where he’s visibly different from White, who is upright and less “interventionalist.” (I’m sorry I couldn’t think of a better word there.)
When squared up in a 1v1, Hincapié gets very close, bends his knees considerably, side-on, and uses short, active steps to keep his balance and delay the attacker. His work on these standing tackles is strong.
That foundation gives him an edge in “contain” scenarios, as he doesn’t often get flat-footed. His full-back experience shows in how he uses the touchline as an extra defender, forcing wide players into predictable lanes and then pouncing when the ball is exposed.
He does, often, blow up the spot on the standing tackle. He wants the winger to know that he’s there. This leads to a good amount of these, where he just tackles through their back.
I had to freeze-frame one of those for my #records.
In more 1v1 situations, he’s just tracking and watching the touch until there’s a time to strike. He always has a bit of a predatory quality.
Here he is against Salah, sprinting back to cover deep and then putting a foot in when Salah tries to cut back.
As we’ve said, and already seen in his brief cameo, he’s very leggy. His legs look long and dextrous, and he tries to wrap them around the opponent to poke the ball free.
In pure 1v1s, his stance stays consistent, his body shape and anticipation are nice, and he’s vibrant and active. He always wants to intervene, as he does here, even though it’s not really “on.”
Generally, he’s doing a much better job of staying on his feet.
In 1v1s, I haven’t witnessed his front-footedness bite much over the last couple of years. He’s played well across matchups, and I haven’t really seen him get cooked. Even when a player like Salah got two assists, it felt more complicated than individual domination. Olise, who was (is) unflappable and technical, was probably the closest. He was responding to Hincapié without concern and got the better of him.
➡️ Defensive Positioning & Space Control
Hincapié is comfortable living in a high line. His pace allows him to squeeze up aggressively, and he’s disciplined about holding general shape, and usually doesn’t play strikers onside with lazy drops. Closer to the box, there’s a chance of him stepping out of formation to stop an attack, which can mix up the line in more settled situations. People don’t tend to think about the offside trap when blocking in your own third, but it’s just as important. Perhaps more important.
In covering actions, he reads danger early and isn’t shy about shuffling across to bail out teammates: he’s a great firefighter. He was often the cover for when a full-back like Grimaldo was having a hard time.
Inside the box, he keeps his feet moving and stays active with small steps, which lets him front attackers without overcommitting. He’s brave enough to get his body in front of shots and generally alert to blindside runs.
He’s a really good box defender, and his qualities and temperament aren’t too different from what Gabriel offers.
He can be a little spinny on shots and rebounds, turning his back on the ball, and his aerial prowess seems a little less imposing when facing strikers in the box as a defender. Things can feel lungy, adding nerves to your viewing, even if it works out in the end.
To me, he might move around a bit too much to be a top back-two CB in the Premier League, but he projects quite well at left-back.
➡️ Pressing & Counterpressing
Hincapié loves making first contact, and doesn’t like waiting for the attacker to settle. He anticipates the next pass and steps in aggressively, often before the receiver has fully opened their body. His acceleration over short distances lets him arrive on touches quickly, which is how he can disrupt so many seemingly simple receptions.
There is some risk. His eagerness can be baited with wall passes. When opponents bounce it around him, the defensive line has to stretch and cover. Sometimes his angles can be too ambitious, and a savvy carrier can use that momentum against him.
Where Hincapié might be at his best is in the half-second after possession is lost. He reacts instantly, getting his body across the opponent, and forcing the regain high, often going to ground, though probably still too much. That “immediate regain” instinct makes him a serious counterpresser, as Timber and Calafiori already are.
In more standard pressing scenarios, he had a keen sense of triggers, and of course, shows reliable effort. Very good projection here.
➡️ Interceptions & Blocking
Hincapié is a jumper who likes to hop forward and cut out passing lanes. Last season, he blocked more passes and shots than any comparable Arsenal defender, and he can turn those moments into quick counters.
When blocking shots, his willingness to sacrifice his body is obvious. But the subtler quality is how he clogs lanes before the shot even comes. He reacts faster than most to a striker loading up.
There are moments when it looks harried and chaotic in the box. I’ve also seen a few instances where I feel he does concede too much space on crosses.
➡️ Recovery Runs & Transition Defending
Hincapié’s recovery runs are one of his calling cards. I find them very charming, and it’s probably one of the reasons that Leverkusen fans liked him so much.
When a line is broken, he can spin and cover ground at full tilt. His angles are usually sharp, and he’s just tireless. You can see him still sprinting at top speed in the dying embers.
If a midfielder like Xhaka lost the ball, Hincapié was quick to slide across and either delay the break or outright snuff it out. His pace is a safety net, but it’s his instinct to react immediately that really limits danger.
As a last-ditch defender, he’s comfortable going to ground with the Ramos-style full-stretch slide that knocks the ball away. I think this is where it’s effective and often fully justified, though sometimes he can take out the man after getting the ball, leading to the appearance (if not the presence) of a foul. He times most of these well.
More often than not, those emergency actions rescue his team from conceding, and they’re part of what makes him such a hard defender to play through. He’s never had a defender like Gabriel behind him, either. The closest is probably Pacho. There’s a chance that could make him more assured, cleaner, perhaps even more opportunistic.
➡️ Aerials and set plays
Hincapié isn’t a mammoth CB, but he’ll be pretty big for a full-back, and he compensates with a springy leap and aggressive timing. Something that can get lost in lineup discussions is that you want a “cumulative” size advantage over your opponent, which helps create mismatches on set plays. Having a bigger full-back helps with that.
In the box, he’s a pretty reliable presence.
One thing you can say without reservation is that he attacks defensive headers rather than waiting for the ball to arrive, getting up early and initiating contact with his arms to gain leverage. He’s rarely bullied, but can meet his match, and isn’t exactly a Van Dijk-style clear-everything presence.
In open play, he’s turned it into a real strength, and assuming he’ll be facing more wingers, I expect this to continue.
His recovery speed helps him get to aerial duels even when initially behind, and he’s comfortable nudging opponents off balance as he jumps. His timing isn’t always perfect, and again, he can be lungy, but his intensity and balance make him difficult to exploit repeatedly.
Hincapié has scored memorable goals, though some of his tools suggest he could score more from set pieces than he does. His headers can be forceful when they land, but there’s variance, too. At minimum, he remains a helpful distraction.
👉 In Attack
Hincapié is really comfortable and coordinated with a ball. He adds security and rhythm in buildup, with clean receiving and line-splitting ground passes that keep play flowing. He can carry forward to commit pressure, but doesn’t pull out too many unexpected ideas. Crossing and switches have promise but haven’t been especially voluminous or deadly.
Historically, his attacking value has been about calma, good fundamentals and timing, few mistakes, and bursty carries.
➡️ Passing (small/tempo)
As a receiver, Hincapié is remarkably clean. His first touch nearly always angles him into the space, giving him natural exits and the ability to modulate tempo. At left-back, this shows in press resistance. He can take the ball under heat, keep it secure, and feed the next line without panic. At LCB, he opens his body well, passes with a crispness, and doesn’t often put his teammates in trouble.
Short passing is his bread and butter, and he generally looks like a player who makes the right choice rather than the flashy one. What’s missing is a lot of footage of him receiving inside the opponent’s block. He seems technically and mentally sharp enough to handle it, but we don’t yet know if he could consistently take on that higher-risk role. I do think that was some of the vision when buying Kiwior, but it didn’t work out.
➡️ Passing (long and/or deadly)
Hincapié has a good left foot, and his long distribution is competent without necessarily being a calling card. Alonso generally wanted to keep the ball on the ground, but Hincapié had a little bit more freedom. Because he had a lot of free touches when facing play, he had a good view.
His long distribution has been pretty similar to Gabriel.
From LCB, he’ll switch play or ping it over the top when space demands it. From LB, he can drop an early ball down the channel, but he’s not quite a ping-it-everywhere quarterback. His technique is clean enough that diagonals usually arrive with pace and accuracy.
Key passes tend to come via line-splitting ground balls.
Those sharp, simple verticals that accelerate play might turn into something special, as they look so natural to him, and the likes of Gyökeres, Martinelli, and Eze would really enjoy being on the other end.
These are the ones that feel most intriguing.
It also means he progresses play reliably. Basically, his long passing is more a useful tool than a weapon opponents must actively scheme against.
Here’s an assist from the half-space, showing he can receive, turn, and deliver a cutback.
While that kind of thing is pretty rare in the footage, there’s not really a physical reason to think he couldn’t do it.
➡️ Crosses
I’d wager that Arsenal scouts feel really good about Hincapié’s crossing potential.
It took me too long to remember that this was now the fourth time I’ve watched this match against Dortmund (once when it happened, once for Gittens, once for Guirassy/Beier, and once now). In any case, this play showcases so much of the vision for Hincapié.
He starts out as a more narrow, hybrid player, then he sneaks behind the press, overburdens the midfield, and goes running and crossing. Once he starts driving with the ball at pace, it’s hard to keep up with him.
Hincapié has the foot for it. There’s clean touch and enough whip. It has been fairly inconsistent, as he can over-or-underhit when rushing the action.
It’s worthwhile to remember just how limited the sample is. His career output includes 91 total league crosses across four seasons, with just 14 reaching the penalty area and none in Leverkusen’s unbeaten year.
He can generate the space he needs to cross, and can bounce between “10/10” deliveries and “5/10” deliveries. This one had some of the meanness to it that you look for.
The strength lies in decision-making. He keeps his head up, surveys, and aims it. He wants to hit them in the head.
➡️ Carrying & Dribbling
Hincapié’s carrying is one of the more exciting parts of his game. He’s quick and coordinated enough to stride past the first presser and commit an extra line of pressure, which can open midfield space for teammates.
As we said, his default body shape when receiving is sound, almost always angling forward, which makes him progressive under pressure.
But his shoulders and hips don’t separate well, so he doesn’t offer disguise on the dribble. He’ll drive straight. It can be a bit awkward in more settled situations. Bradley rekked him:
Hincapié can turn pretty quickly in recovery or when pressed, though I just haven’t seen him a lot through the middle. His turning mechanics look efficient enough to face forward and drive into space. But there are unknowns there.
This is the idea, and when he looks most natural.
When he gets going, the stride is genuinely powerful and coordinated, and he can bypass an entire pressing line. In tighter spaces, I don’t know, it’s less interesting.
➡️ Ball-striking
Hincapié strikes the ball cleanly off his left foot. Winding up, the technique is ramrod straight and powerful. He just hits through it. That can still create awkward rebounds or second balls, but he’s never scored from range.
In terms of generating shots, most of his involvement comes in the second phase after set pieces, where his reactions and willingness to stay alive in the box create chances. He’ll gamble on loose balls and isn’t shy about putting his foot through a bouncing clearance, which can lead to scrappy but valuable shots.
What he doesn’t provide is the polished long-range strike or the pass-shot hybrid thing that some left-footed defenders offer. His value is more in being present and aggressive in advanced situations. I don’t doubt he could add bangers to his game in the future. His contact is usually clean.
➡️ Throw-ins
I promised myself I’d pay a little attention to something that Arsenal don’t typically seem to value much, which is throw-in ability.
…I’m afraid I don’t have many interesting insights to share.
He looks like a standard full-back. Normal distance, normal release, nothing out of the ordinary.
🏥 Injury history
Hincapié has shown the kind of durability you want in a defender asked to cover huge ground every week.
Source: Transfermarkt
He’s made 26+ league appearances in four straight seasons at Leverkusen, with only two minor issues over four straight years. Unlike Calafiori, Tomiyasu, or Zinchenko, whose availability has been an ongoing issue, Hincapié has a history of combining athleticism with robustness. Of course, you never know. Merino was hurt in his first training, and Timber tore his ACL right away. But you can only control what you can control.
It’s a demanding role, and part of “athleticism” is “doing hard things without your body breaking down.” He has a great base, which raises the floor of the signing.
“My best position is centre-back. I've played many games at full-back as well, but I think I'm best at centre-back. As for my qualities, I'm pacey and I like carrying the ball forward as well as being a leader on the pitch.”
Sometimes I’ll fill this space with more speculative positional projections. With Hincapié, I’d predict something simpler. I think he’s mostly going to play left-back for Arsenal. It’s, at least, what I would do.
It dovetails neatly with the other signings, and it gives Arteta a profile he’s been missing, which is an athletic, front-foot full-back who isn’t a defensive liability on set pieces and can still keep build-up clean.
In practice, that role will stay relatively wide. The logic is threefold:
Keep the inside channel clear so players like Eze can push inside. (Yes, I think Hincapié will really enable that.)
Have someone who can hit direct channel passes for Gyökeres.
Leave the central receiving and progression to the double pivot.
Within that framework, Hincapié’s job is part defensive stopper, part safe outlet. His role will be to step hard on counters, win duels in space, then recycle or carry the ball forward to reset the structure. His ability to drive up the line and deliver a cross adds a layer Arsenal haven’t consistently had from defensive-minded left-backs, and it could help manage Calafiori’s workload across the season.
I personally believe a healthy Calafiori will be difficult to unseat in most matches, but there’s another thing this opens up, which is the idea of Hincapié at LB and Calafiori at LCB, with Calafiori driving forward and doing whatever he wants while Hincapié covers.
I imagine Hincapié will float centrally less than Calafiori or Lewis-Skelly do. I don’t really put it past him to be able to receive in a pivot, but I don’t anticipate it being a large part of his game. I do think he’d be pretty confident in the left half-space in more advanced play.
For those of us who maintain hope of situational “twin-10” lineups with Rice or Zubimendi at the base and some combination of Ødegaard/Eze/Nwaneri ahead, this helps that along.
The “2-3” base shape in advanced areas would be Gabriel and Saliba in back, and the likes of Hincapié, Zubimendi, and Timber as the second line. Those two lines are about as good at counter-pressing as a human could devise in a lab, and have serious recovery pace. With the LB not gallivanting as much, it gives you the ability to throw whatever five attackers you want, in my opinion.
He could also, basically, just hang out at LW as White has done on the other side, holding width for most of the match while everybody else overloads the middle.
The only other role he’s likely to see is at LCB. I’d personally consider that more of a secondary option than a default, given that I’d probably have Gabriel, Saliba, Mosquera, and Calafiori ahead of him there, but it also depends on fitness and the qualities of the partnership and a lot else. Still, his experience in Alonso’s back-three means he’s a credible cover piece when Arsenal play with a double pivot or need a more aggressive LCB, and it’s definitely an option in cups and the like, where I could see a Mosquera/Hincapié duo playing.
In general, though, Hincapié’s running power, defensive range, and composure on the ball make him a pretty natural defender for Arsenal, particularly at left-back.
🔥 Final Analysis
We’ve talked before about how the sequencing of the Noni Madueke signing shaped its reception. If he had been the third, rather than the first, attacking arrival this summer, the reaction would probably have been euphoric, a rightful response to a statement of real ambition. Turns out, it was.
Piero Hincapié’s case is almost the opposite. He arrived late in the window, after our Arsenal had already signaled this would be a big and expensive summer aimed at fixing depth, once and for all. With so many arrivals, Hincapié felt like a cherry on top, escaping much scrutiny.
But this is not a minor deal. €52 million is significant. It’s the second-largest defender signing in club history, after Ben White. It is a top-25 fee worldwide this year (though it’s technically next year), and more expensive than players like Milos Kerkez, Jorrel Hato, Jeremie Frimpong, Rayan Aït-Nouri, or Rayan Cherki. Timing aside, it deserves a proper look.
🐻 Bear case
Most players have worse bear cases. This signing is highly risk-mitigated. He is the perfect age, he is highly experienced, he is athletic and physical, he is flexible, his intensity and fitness will almost assuredly translate, and there is a wide range of footage, data, and individual matchups you can use to increase your certainty level. If it does not work out, he will have suitors in a year or two.
So what does a bear case look like?
The most realistic “bear” scenario is that he is a “nearly” defender rather than a foundational one, roughly on the level of Kiwior or slightly above, but missing that last notch to truly move the dial.
His aggression, while more controlled now, still gets caught out because the Premier League is crueller to aggressive angles than other leagues. If you have a jump that works on Patrick Wimmer, it may not work on Jérémy Doku. Along the way, he loses some players on quick 1-2s, and also picks up a few unfortunate cards.
The possibility of reds is the bearest of bear cases.
In attack, the negative view is more about limited impact. I have little doubt he will be a clean, measured, mature presence in build-up. But full-backs have become so integral to Arsenal’s creativity and vibrancy, and the question is whether he will be able to split apart blocks on his own. If the crosses are a little loopy, the carrying finds less space, and the dribbling stays at its current level, he will be a floor-raiser but not a ceiling-raiser.
He could also prove avoidable as a Premier League centre-back because of jumpiness and size, which locks him into a single role.
Basically, this is a lot of money, and if Hincapié is merely a strong rotational option, we may rue the opportunity cost and wish we had gone the more incisive route of a Hato, a freakier talent like Baldé, or even another unicorn like Bastoni. Easy to say from this vantage point.
🐮 Bull case
The optimistic scenario is that Hincapié develops into one of the Premier League’s best left-sided defenders, marrying his athletic base with a final layer of incisive attacking play. He has the brain, body, and attitude to do it.
In this scenario, he helps Arsenal swarm opponents to an absurd degree. He fortifies what’s already the world’s strongest defensive unit, but adds something unique to the wide defending, outside of Timber: a front-footedness, urgency, fight, and aggression to make it work. This creates the attacking “net” where the ball is endlessly pinned because teams can’t play out, producing more chances.
This has a temperamental effect on the team, and helps transmit a sense of urgency to everyone, especially on the left.
I think fans will like him a lot. xDog is off the charts.
At left-back, his secure receiving, clean feel for tempo, assured passing, and ability to stride into space can tilt games Arsenal’s way.
His recovery pace makes the whole “hybrid full-back” idea feel like no tradeoff at all. He has the potential to be a true stopper, a thorn in the side for great wingers.
With coaching, especially from Gabriel Heinze, he can add the final elements to his attacking repertoire: more consistent crossing, tighter combinations upfield, and become a force multiplier for the attackers.
This has four notable effects:
Eze reaches his top level by drifting inside.
Calafiori stays healthier with rotation, perhaps playing more LCB.
The midfield can better mix shapes (double pivot, single pivot).
Lewis-Skelly grows into his midfield future.
Another beneficiary could be Gyökeres, who thrives on the channel balls Hincapié already hits well.
His engine lets Arsenal maintain and extend leads late in games. If he starts, he doesn’t need to come off at 70 minutes. If he doesn’t start, he comes in and goes full throttle.
He’s also a real threat on set pieces. There are some potential goals in his game if he’s pushed further up.
I generally feel quite optimistic about the summer and Arsenal’s chances overall. I also feel great about Hincapié’s energy, application, and willingness (and ability) to iron out weaknesses. He has the foundation to become great. I still have questions about some of his duel approaches, his angles, and whether he can add that final level of attacking thrust to split open blocks.
In Argentina, they welcomed him to Córdoba with the nickname “El pibe con el nombre raro,” or “the lad with the unusual name.”
“That’s good,” he said. “The accent is unusual and that means the name is pronounced in a completely different way. I like the sound of it, which is why I emphasise it that way. But I think the accent on the shirt looks daft, which is why it isn’t there. I still haven’t fully made up my mind.”
My googling tells me that his name’s origin is thought to be from the phrase “hacer hincapié,” literally “to make a foothold” or “to stomp with the foot.” Metaphorically, it means to give something emphasis, to stress it, to persist.
Hincapié is nothing if not persistent.
My newsletter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and to keep this kind of thing going, please consider becoming a paid subscriber.
Excellent analysis but I do wonder if the next evolution of Arsenal is a 3-4-3 or 3-4-2-1 with a defender dropping out - particularly at home against low blocks. I always saw Eze and Odegaard as twin 10s sitting just behind the 9, but you can't get wingers, Rice and Zubi in without dropping a defender (who often you don't need anyway). The other option is a narrow front 3, with wingbacks - which I see as a "give the wingers a rest" formation for a cup game.
Excellent analysis but I do wonder if the next evolution of Arsenal is a 3-4-3 or 3-4-2-1 with a defender dropping out - particularly at home against low blocks. I always saw Eze and Odegaard as twin 10s sitting just behind the 9, but you can't get wingers, Rice and Zubi in without dropping a defender (who often you don't need anyway). The other option is a narrow front 3, with wingbacks - which I see as a "give the wingers a rest" formation for a cup game.
Billy. The intros with the quotes. I don’t know how you do it but they are just so satisfying and thought provoking.