24 Comments
User's avatar
Daniel Ambrus's avatar

After just a few months of discovering your stuff, I'm already a huge fan. If there's a more thorough, more thoughtful, better presented blog for high level Arsenal analysis, I haven't found it. The sheer number of hours you must put into these articles blows my mind. Thank you for doing what you do.

Tom Curren's avatar

Opening a football blog with Blood Meridian is the hardest thing I’ve ever seen

Lucas's avatar

Thoughts on Arsenal-Brighton (minus the endless complains on the red card!)

- We could have won it. Speaks a lot about the team.

- Declan needed a break. He has one now!

- Defending for equalizer was shocking.

- Raya’s been immense.

- Timber inverting needs more work. Defensively solid though.

Extra thoughts on Arsenal fans:

Yes, the refereeing standards are beyond despicable for all clubs for the last 3 seasons. Yes, the two points lost may haunt us in our title race.

However, I’m calm. I remember the banter era, the toxic end to Wenger’s reign, the absolute repulsion to watching our football under Unai Emery, the toxicity festering within the stadium during those dark days.

Learn to enjoy what we have, now that we are near our best. Because I sure as hell remember when we were at our worst. Live it. Breath it.

Le Groove (not Pedro)'s avatar

Cormac’s best book. This blog has everything.

Owen Talmage's avatar

Great read. In my eyes, partey was the weakest link against Brighton and Rice should be back in the 6- while he’s out, what do you think the midfield might look like? I would like to see nwaneri but I don’t think arteta will want him starting against spurs.

Billy Carpenter's avatar

I’d personally probably do Jorginho/Havertz or something goofier, but expect Partey/Havertz

Maulanna Maryunani-Enoch's avatar

If you're paywalling the Neto scouting report, it better has multiple childhood photos of him wearing Arsenal kits, Billy.

Eric Robinson's avatar

Whoa. Thanks for the incredible post, Billy. Brilliant. Learning so much from your analysis, and enjoying the comedy and deeper observations along the way. All in. Subscribed today!

Andrew Barry's avatar

Øverlap 😂

stephen page's avatar

As for the 3 games thus far, something that I don’t think is being spoken of enough is the return of Timber FROM AN ACL. Some (many?) supporters and commentators appear to be have completely overlooked this. I think it could be a few months before he’s fully up to speed. People should give the guy some slack; he’s gong to be a huge player for the team if he stays fit.

Billy Carpenter's avatar

Agreed.

Also, he's [inverting into midfield] from [left-back].

ie., doing [a new thing] in [probably his third-best position]

stephen page's avatar

Billy, looking forward to “extra time”. I’m

one of those that wants to move to penalties, seeing an additional 30 minutes as invariably a period of poor play. But definitely not in your case…

Rithvik Balakrishnan's avatar

Love the reference to Glengarry Glen Ross. Wonderful piece as always Billy.

Owen's avatar

“Crosses are for closers,” was the first thing that came to mind after reading. Thanks as always, Billy!

Steg's avatar

Hai Caramba. Magnificent piece of writing that!

Fábio da Graça's avatar

Thank you, great read!

Eric Burkley's avatar

Really appreciate this Substack. Great stuff, Billy.

Bosk's avatar

Thanks Billy, great write up 👌🏾